Wip Talk
Post to the Talk Blog »

« Social and Psychological Well-Being: Alternative Health and Healing in Haiti (Part II) | Main | Don Quijote No Ha Muerto »

April 13, 2010

Madonna, The Aging Rock Star




I was watching TV recently when three news anchors, two females and one male, began speaking about Madonna’s new clothing line inspired by Lourdes, her teenage daughter. What upset me was that she was inappropriately referred to as an “aging rock star” by the two news anchors and their co-anchor standing by the sidelines. It started with the female anchor, sarcastically stating, “If you want a line by an aging rock star……”

I feel her tone of voice and choice of words was unnecessary and insulting to Madonna and to women as a whole because it screams of sexism. I’m not even sure I can call it sexism because it was perpetuated by women on a fellow woman.

It’s no news that the music industry is struggling and everyone including Madonna must find ways to reinvent themselves to remain relevant and make money by connecting to a wider audience and including younger demographics, however her creating a clothing line shouldn’t induce such negative comments.

Madonna at 61 is no spring chicken, but saying she’s “an aging rock star” is unfair. Who refers to Paul McCartney, Mick Jagger or Bono as aging rock stars? These men are all in the same category of recording artists who have passed their prime, but men “don’t age” only women do. In fact, as they get older they are considered hot. Ke$ha in her recent hit song, Tik Tok sings, “And now, the dudes are lining up cause they hear we got swagger. But we kick em to the curb unless they look like Mick Jagger.” At 66, Mick Jagger as far as Ke$ha and so many other women worldwide are concerned is still a hottie. Though in reality age is nothing but a number, we see the double standards clearly.

We women are sometimes our own worst enemies. These two female news anchors who are relatively young now think its funny referring to Madonna that way but what they forget is that they are all in the very vain looks based entertainment industry and as my mother says, when I laugh at the many things she can no longer do, “keep on living, your time is coming.” Needless to say, these tactless news anchors won’t be young forever, and they will become aging news anchors fearing being replaced by younger perkier versions.

If the male correspondence started it, I would have said he was just a male chauvinist pig being insensitive, but a female news anchor started it and he just laughed. When the other female news anchor repeated what the first one said, I just shook my head in disbelief. If the male news anchor had made the statement, I would’ve expected one or both of the women to make remarks to put him in his place but no, we woman can do a good job of saying something offensive to depict our fellow woman in a negative light as if we don’t have enough negativity coming at us already.

We all know that to men, women’s youth and beauty are prized possessions. That’s why many men trade their wives in for newer models, as aptly depicted in the movie, The First Wives Club but when women are the first to make unprompted disparaging remarks about another woman’s youth or beauty, I find it particularly offensive.

If you haven’t been privy to watching women talk negatively about other women’s looks, watch a couple of episodes of America’s Next Top Model. That will fill you in. Keep in mind that these are all gorgeous girls vying to become top models and you’ll be amazed at how they often have no problem bad mouthing each other’s looks so I guess after watching that, Madonna being called an aging rock star shouldn't be too surprising to me.

As people, we all age, Madonna included. I say shame on these news anchors that have nothing better to do than to make fun of her instead of commending her on how hard she works to look as good as she does for her age and her strength for staying relevant in the ever tumultuous entertainment industry for as long as she has.

I would like to implore all women to consciously remember to be kind when talking about other women. This is one of the simplest ways to pay it forward for other women.

Comments (3)

Flea:

This editorial states that Madonna's age is 61 (sixty one), when in fact, at the time of this writing, Madonna is currently age 51.

I think aspects of this editorial are naive. Liberal women pretend to be feminists, yet they will insult and mock conservative females. There is no sisterhood, so making appeals to the "all women must stick together" sentiment rings rather hollow.

Considering that Madonna has been rude to other females over her life time, from her childhood on into her adulthood (many examples could be cited, here's but one: Madonna 'trash talked' female politician Sarah Palin on a recent tour, stating she wanted to 'kick Palin's butt' or something to that effect), why should all women automatically come to Madonna's defense?

Madonna willingly chose to enter a profession (pop singer) in which youth is highly prized.

Nobody forced Madonna to enter this type of career. Madonna could have chosen to become a school teacher, librarian, house wife, plumber, dog walker, or any number of other occupations that did not place such a huge emphasis upon physical appearance. As such, she is not completely undeserving of barbs about looking older, looking too thin, or unattractive.

Maybe the younger women would not laugh at and ridicule Madonna if Madonna behaved and dressed like a 51 year old; instead, Madonna tries to remain relevant by continuing to dress, behave, and pose for many photo spreads (when promoting new albums) as though she is still 25 years old.

That Madonna is now using her teen daughter Lourdes to make in-roads with today's teens smacks even more of desperation.

Flea:

Post Script.) And yes, I've seen plenty examples of the main stream media and every day, regular people on entertainment blogs, poking fun at and ridiculing famous males based upon their looks. I've seen chubby or wrinkled male celebrities, such as Val Kilmer and Mick Jagger, picked on.

When male actor Gerard Butler (of the film "300") gained a lot of weight recently and photos of him looking tubby appeared in the tabloids, he was ridiculed quite a bit on the blogs for it.

Maybe there used to be a double standard in the entertainment industry, but these days, males get laughed at and mocked if they look old, flabby, and out of shape, too. Men are not immune from criticism in this area.

Stating Madonna's age as 61 is a typo on my part that I didn't catch before publishing the piece. I apologize for that. However, based on the comments, my blog post must’ve touched a nerve, and it appears more than what I wrote was read into it.

I’m guessing Flea isn’t Madonna’s fan. Aspects of the editorial may be “naïve” and Madonna may have said offensive things about other women, but that doesn’t make it right for Madonna or anyone else to do so. I don’t know where the “Liberal women pretend to be feminists, yet they will insult and mock conservative females” came from but that is a generalization.

My blog post is not about liberal vs. conservative women and asking women to not start or encourage negative remarks regarding other women’s ages is about sharing kindness among women, a sentiment which understandably may ring rather hollow to some, because they haven’t benefited from it. As a person who has benefited from some sisterhood among women, I know it makes all the difference.

That Madonna willingly chose to enter a profession where youth is highly prized is true but regardless of career field, women still experience some age ridicule because often a woman’s worth is based on her age and looks. Any person, male or female, should not be ridiculed because of their age.

Staying relevant by posing for photo spreads when promoting new albums is part of Madonna's job, and creating a clothing line inspired by her daughter is not “using her teen daughter,” nor does it show desperation. It’s just another career field she has chosen to explore like other people do. Double standards still exist, and male celebrities being ridiculed for their unhealthy looks is not the same as Madonna being ridiculed for her normal age progression because you can do a lot to manage your looks but you can’t do anything about your age.

Ultimately, what everyone including the news anchors and Madonna should remember is that if one doesn’t have something nice to say, it’s best one doesn’t say anything at all.

Ad Space Holder

Leave a comment